I remember this being argued at the seminary, with one seminarian holding that the problem of Mass stipends was an argument against concelebration. Apparently, it isn't. Fr. Hunwicke: Benedict XIV on Concelebration and Money and Concelebration.
See also: S Thomas on Concelebration and Pope Innocent III on Concelebration
Wednesday, May 13, 2015
Nit-Picking
Guest-note: Did one of the main Vatican II documents distort the Words of Our Lord in the Gospel?
John Lamont: "For non-Latinists, this claim (it is a complete sentence in the conciliar document) can be translated as follows: 'For love of God and of neighbour is the first and greatest commandment'. No Latin is needed to realise that this is a flat contradiction of the teaching of Christ. There is a deliberate allusion in Gaudium et Spes 24 to the wording of the divine teaching it is contradicting, as can be seen from looking at the Vulgate text of that teaching..."
The second can be considered a part of first, in so far as the first provides the justification and the motivation for the second.
St. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae II II 44, 2:
"The love of God is the end to which the love of our neighbor is directed. Therefore it behooved us to receive precepts not only of the love of God but also of the love of our neighbor, on account of those who are less intelligent, who do not easily understand that one of these precepts is included in the other."
See also II II 25, 1.
An embarrassing critique. Latin traditionalists really should be more circumspect, lest their zeal to conserve what they think to be Catholic teaching leads them to errors such as this. (A poor foundation in theology? Even a good conservative Thomist, or a good Thomist of "strict observance" would no better than to offer this.)
John Lamont: "For non-Latinists, this claim (it is a complete sentence in the conciliar document) can be translated as follows: 'For love of God and of neighbour is the first and greatest commandment'. No Latin is needed to realise that this is a flat contradiction of the teaching of Christ. There is a deliberate allusion in Gaudium et Spes 24 to the wording of the divine teaching it is contradicting, as can be seen from looking at the Vulgate text of that teaching..."
The second can be considered a part of first, in so far as the first provides the justification and the motivation for the second.
St. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae II II 44, 2:
"The love of God is the end to which the love of our neighbor is directed. Therefore it behooved us to receive precepts not only of the love of God but also of the love of our neighbor, on account of those who are less intelligent, who do not easily understand that one of these precepts is included in the other."
See also II II 25, 1.
An embarrassing critique. Latin traditionalists really should be more circumspect, lest their zeal to conserve what they think to be Catholic teaching leads them to errors such as this. (A poor foundation in theology? Even a good conservative Thomist, or a good Thomist of "strict observance" would no better than to offer this.)
Groundbreaking for St. Elias Church (Brampton)
more great pictures- R. Dashko
Posted by Saint Elias Church Brampton, Ontario Canada on Tuesday, May 12, 2015
groundbreaking!https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.972647492779520.1073741829.959006327476970&type=1
Posted by Saint Elias Church Brampton, Ontario Canada on Sunday, May 10, 2015
Related:
New photos!http://www.sainteliaschurch.tumblr.com/latestphotos
Posted by Saint Elias Church Brampton, Ontario Canada on Sunday, May 3, 2015
Pascha at St.Elias [2015] Parish in Brampton Ontario Canada.Пасха [2015] в церкві Святого Пророка Божого Іллі в Канадіhttps://youtu.be/veK5g_Wp0Lg
Posted by Saint Elias Church Brampton, Ontario Canada on Saturday, April 25, 2015
PART 2Pascha at St.Elias [2015] Parish in Brampton Ontario Canada.Пасха [2015] в церкві Святого Пророка Божого Іллі в Канадіhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0sZn8Ns6F94&feature=em-subs_digest-vrecs
Posted by Saint Elias Church Brampton, Ontario Canada on Thursday, April 30, 2015
St. John the Baptist Greek Orthodox Church
Las Vegas -- if I'm ever in Vegas again...
Salutation of the Theotokos at St John the Baptist Greek Orthodox Church, Las Vegas.
Posted by Orthodox Christian Network on Tuesday, May 12, 2015
Contemplation as "Silence"
Seeking Silence: An Interview with Kevin M. Johnson - The Inner Room (FB)
BC
An emphasis on nous; no such thing as Catholic silence or Catholic contemplation? What about Christian contemplation? There is no real mysticism without Christ. Too much of an "interfaith," interdisciplinary approach to contemplation that tries to engage modern Western philosophy as well? I prefer explanations by Fr. Bouyer, Archimandrite Gabriel Bunge or Fr. Jean Corbon. Contemplation is not the same as meditation, though it may make use of it.
The Liturgy Lived: The Divinization of Man | Jean Corbon, O.P. (from The Wellspring of Worship) [excerpt recently republished here]
Dialoguing About Silence
In Pursuit of Silence - FB
Our current director, Kevin M Johnson was involved in a long interview about silence and The Inner Room with Artur Sebastian Rosman.
Posted by The Inner Room on Tuesday, May 12, 2015
BC
An emphasis on nous; no such thing as Catholic silence or Catholic contemplation? What about Christian contemplation? There is no real mysticism without Christ. Too much of an "interfaith," interdisciplinary approach to contemplation that tries to engage modern Western philosophy as well? I prefer explanations by Fr. Bouyer, Archimandrite Gabriel Bunge or Fr. Jean Corbon. Contemplation is not the same as meditation, though it may make use of it.
The Liturgy Lived: The Divinization of Man | Jean Corbon, O.P. (from The Wellspring of Worship) [excerpt recently republished here]
Dialoguing About Silence
In Pursuit of Silence - FB
We're finally getting around to posting our first trailer that we put together last year. Hope you'll take the time to watch and share. #pursuitofsilence
Posted by In Pursuit of Silence - A Documentary Film on Monday, March 2, 2015
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)