The Hermeneutic of Continuity: Nail-biting SSPX developments
Friday, June 15, 2012
Not Understanding Nothing
A review of A Universe from Nothing
Edward Feser
Oxford Handbook of Aquinas
A review of A Universe from Nothing
Edward Feser
Oxford Handbook of Aquinas
Labels:
books,
Edward Feser,
philosophy of science,
physics,
St. Thomas Aquinas
Thursday, June 14, 2012
Wednesday, June 13, 2012
Lee Faber, Note on Some Translations of Scotus
I relied more on the English translation by Wolter for studying Scotus than on the original Latin.
I relied more on the English translation by Wolter for studying Scotus than on the original Latin.
MOJ: "Much Ado About Subsidiarity" (which links to this post at VN, which notably does not offer a definition of the common good, but one assumes that the one current in CST is implied). Garnett cites Russell Hittinger for an explanation of subsidiarity, and Hittinger adequately presents contemporary teaching on the concept. What is missing, to circumscribe the definition of subsidiarity and the state? A notion of the common good (life in community) that is tied to an understanding of the proper human scale.
If the common goods that exist at different "levels" do not have the same definition, then how can there be an ordered hierarchy of authorities serving them? If common good1 is not a part of common good 2, then how can authority1 be subordinate to authority2? An authority that serves to preserve the peace of many communities cannot have any sort of authority over the communities themselves - this would go beyond its competence.
If the common goods that exist at different "levels" do not have the same definition, then how can there be an ordered hierarchy of authorities serving them? If common good1 is not a part of common good 2, then how can authority1 be subordinate to authority2? An authority that serves to preserve the peace of many communities cannot have any sort of authority over the communities themselves - this would go beyond its competence.
Labels:
common good,
community,
politike,
Russell Hittinger,
subsidiarity
Tuesday, June 12, 2012
I was going through old mail and found a solicitation for Spiritual Life: A Journal of Contemporary Spirituality. Apparently the magazine is still in existence. Is the mass media format of the magazine or journal amenable to teaching about the spiritual life? Or shouldn't it deserve more of an extended treatment? (Or even better, a living guide?) Not everything can be disseminated through the mass media well.
Catholic Church Conservation: Dominican Monks Dance Like Lady Gaga
Good-natured fun, or a display of immaturity and the lack of good judgment? Despite discernment to the priesthood or religious life being postponed until much later in life, has the infantilization that plagues mass industrial 'cultures' affected our seminarians and young adults as well? Fortunately there are not more videos of seminarians doing goofy things - the Star Wars video is still up, though. (Those discerning religious life may be more mature, in so far as it is more demanding than the seminary.)
(How much of this might be due to contemporary "psychology," the need to have a personality and such, versus acquiring virtues nad properly fulfilling a function in caritas and community?)
Something from an older Dominican, fr Wojciech Giertych OP:
Papal Theologian on the 'Pange Lingua'
Good-natured fun, or a display of immaturity and the lack of good judgment? Despite discernment to the priesthood or religious life being postponed until much later in life, has the infantilization that plagues mass industrial 'cultures' affected our seminarians and young adults as well? Fortunately there are not more videos of seminarians doing goofy things - the Star Wars video is still up, though. (Those discerning religious life may be more mature, in so far as it is more demanding than the seminary.)
(How much of this might be due to contemporary "psychology," the need to have a personality and such, versus acquiring virtues nad properly fulfilling a function in caritas and community?)
Something from an older Dominican, fr Wojciech Giertych OP:
Papal Theologian on the 'Pange Lingua'
Labels:
Dominicans,
St. Thomas Aquinas,
Wojciech Giertych OP
Monday, June 11, 2012
Sunday, June 10, 2012
Saturday, June 09, 2012
Rome Reports: Convents and monasteries survive on their online stores
What are they going to do as the price of oil goes up higher? They need to start adjusting now.
What are they going to do as the price of oil goes up higher? They need to start adjusting now.
Friday, June 08, 2012
Mattias Caro, Is There Such a Thing as Inalienable Rights?. He refers to Rights You Can't Give Away.
Do we need to take Jefferson's rhetoric (or his theory of rights) so seriously?
Do we need to take Jefferson's rhetoric (or his theory of rights) so seriously?
James Chastek, Integral truth
Mr. Chastek compares theological truth with food and relates both to multiple ends. G-L is making a point though about the epistemology of those supporting the development of a new, up-to-date theology. If theology is not true, then how can it benefit or aid modern man and his vexations? Do we know God via things? Or do we know God through our ideas?
We could also ask the question of whether theology is more speculative or practical in nature.
Mr. Chastek compares theological truth with food and relates both to multiple ends. G-L is making a point though about the epistemology of those supporting the development of a new, up-to-date theology. If theology is not true, then how can it benefit or aid modern man and his vexations? Do we know God via things? Or do we know God through our ideas?
We could also ask the question of whether theology is more speculative or practical in nature.
Labels:
good,
James Chastek,
Reginald Garrigou-Lagrange,
theology
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)