Sunday, September 11, 2011
Saturday, September 10, 2011
The Smithy: Henry of Ghent on Aquinas and Existence
Henry of Ghent: "The first way of understanding the participation of a creature in being is mistaken; it is not an understanding but a phantastical imagination. For the essence of a creature should not be imagined like the air indifferent to obscurity and luminosity, but like a certain ray in itself apt to subsist, produced by the sun, not by the necessity of nature but by free will."
Isn't it rather petty to complain that an analogy is a phantastical imagination rather than an understanding?
But does Aquinas think that existence and nature are two separate things? How can they be distinct without being separate in reality? How is "real" to be understood? After all, St. Thomas's and the Thomistic understanding of the real distinction is what is at issue...
Henry of Ghent: "The first way of understanding the participation of a creature in being is mistaken; it is not an understanding but a phantastical imagination. For the essence of a creature should not be imagined like the air indifferent to obscurity and luminosity, but like a certain ray in itself apt to subsist, produced by the sun, not by the necessity of nature but by free will."
Isn't it rather petty to complain that an analogy is a phantastical imagination rather than an understanding?
Thomas' image of the air's illumination is an image of one sort of thing being poured into another sort of thing to make it actual in a certain way, but for Henry (and, I might add, the Franciscan tradition in general along with him) existence can't be understood as a different sort of thing than the existing nature and added to it in order that it can be.
But does Aquinas think that existence and nature are two separate things? How can they be distinct without being separate in reality? How is "real" to be understood? After all, St. Thomas's and the Thomistic understanding of the real distinction is what is at issue...
Labels:
Franciscan school,
metaphysics,
St. Thomas Aquinas
Friday, September 09, 2011
Discussion of Peter Moskos's book on punishment
Public Discourse: Flogging: The Best Hope for Our Broken Prison System? by Stefan McDaniel
More on the book.
More on the book.
Thursday, September 08, 2011
Wednesday, September 07, 2011
Tuesday, September 06, 2011
Zenit: On Beauty as a Way to God
Art "Is Like a Door Opened to the Infinite"
Sandro Magister, Ratzinger's Favorite Bach Cantata
It is the one for the last Sunday of the Lutheran liturgical year, centered on the parable of the wise and foolish virgins. All the details of a personal memory of Pope Benedict, on the eve of his next voyage to Germany
Art "Is Like a Door Opened to the Infinite"
Sandro Magister, Ratzinger's Favorite Bach Cantata
It is the one for the last Sunday of the Lutheran liturgical year, centered on the parable of the wise and foolish virgins. All the details of a personal memory of Pope Benedict, on the eve of his next voyage to Germany
Monday, September 05, 2011
Sunday, September 04, 2011
Righteous
What are the Greek and Hebrew words which are translated by the word "righteous" or "just"? The Online Etymological Dictionary has the following for "righteous":
And for right:
The word can describe a person with respect to his actions in relation to God. (His moral orientation?) Is this what is conveyed by the Hebrew and Greek?
early 16c. alteration of rightwise, from O.E. rihtwis, from riht (see right) + wis "wise, way, manner." Suffix altered by influence of courteous, etc. Meaning "genuine, excellent" is c.1900 in jazz slang. Related: Righteousness.
And for right:
"Straight" as describing the path one takes [to God]?right (adj.1)"morally correct," O.E. riht "just, good, fair, proper, fitting, straight," from P.Gmc. *rekhtaz (cf. O.H.G. reht, Ger. recht, O.N. rettr, Goth. raihts), from PIE base *reg- "move in a straight line," also "to rule, to lead straight, to put right" (see regal; cf. Gk. orektos "stretched out, upright;" L. rectus "straight, right;" O.Pers. rasta- "straight, right," aršta- "rectitude;" O.Ir. recht "law;" Welsh rhaith, Breton reiz "just, righteous, wise").
The word can describe a person with respect to his actions in relation to God. (His moral orientation?) Is this what is conveyed by the Hebrew and Greek?
Labels:
biblical theology,
etymology,
grace,
infused virtues,
justice
Coming up at the Church of St. Vincent Ferrer, NYC
OpStJoseph: Solemn Vespers for All Saints Eve
Liturgy and Lecture at St. Vincent Ferrer with Fr. Uwe Michael Lang
By Fr. Lang:
The Reform of the Liturgy and the Position of the Celebrant at the Altar
The Language of Liturgical Celebration
How Latin Could Serve as a "Bond of Unity"
Fr. Uwe Michael Lang on Latin in the Liturgy
Liturgy and Lecture at St. Vincent Ferrer with Fr. Uwe Michael Lang
By Fr. Lang:
The Reform of the Liturgy and the Position of the Celebrant at the Altar
The Language of Liturgical Celebration
How Latin Could Serve as a "Bond of Unity"
Fr. Uwe Michael Lang on Latin in the Liturgy
Saturday, September 03, 2011
John Deely has been busy.
But is he rewiting the same book? From U. of Scranton Press:
Descartes and Poinsot: The Crossroad of Signs and Ideas
Augustine and Poinsot: The Protosemiotic Development
Medieval Philosophy Redefined: The Development of Cenoscopic Science, AD354 to 1644 (From the Birth of Augustine to the Death of Poinsot)
Forthcoming
Intentionality and Semiotics: A Story of Mutual Fecundation (also available)
Did he take his history of philosophy and expand certain chapters?
Four Ages of Understanding: The first Postmodern Survey of Philosophy from Ancient Times to the Turn of the Twenty-First Century (GB)
Descartes and Poinsot: The Crossroad of Signs and Ideas
Augustine and Poinsot: The Protosemiotic Development
Medieval Philosophy Redefined: The Development of Cenoscopic Science, AD354 to 1644 (From the Birth of Augustine to the Death of Poinsot)
Intentionality and Semiotics: A Story of Mutual Fecundation (also available)
Did he take his history of philosophy and expand certain chapters?
Four Ages of Understanding: The first Postmodern Survey of Philosophy from Ancient Times to the Turn of the Twenty-First Century (GB)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)