Vultus Christi: Only God Himself, His Word and His Signs
Monday, September 26, 2011
Sunday, September 25, 2011
First Things: The Case Against False Assertions by Christopher Tollefsen and Alexander Pruss
Edit. In the comments someone mentions this paper by Alasdair MacIntyre: Truthfulness, Lies, and Moral Philosophers.
Edit. In the comments someone mentions this paper by Alasdair MacIntyre: Truthfulness, Lies, and Moral Philosophers.
Friday, September 23, 2011
Rome Reports: Pope: “I came to Germany to speak about God”
Zenit:
The Pope Has Come to Germany, He Speaks of God
L'Osservatore Director Reflects on First Days of State Visit
Zenit:
The Pope Has Come to Germany, He Speaks of God
L'Osservatore Director Reflects on First Days of State Visit
Pontiff's Reflections at Marian Shrine [2011-09-23]
"At the Foot of the Cross, Mary Becomes Our Fellow Traveler and Protector"
"At the Foot of the Cross, Mary Becomes Our Fellow Traveler and Protector"
Papal Homily at Ecumenical Prayer Service [2011-09-23]
"In the Prayer of Jesus We Find the Very Heart of Our Unity"
"In the Prayer of Jesus We Find the Very Heart of Our Unity"
Papal Words to Germany's Evangelical Church [2011-09-23]
"God Is Increasingly Being Driven Out of Our Society"
"God Is Increasingly Being Driven Out of Our Society"
Benedict XVI's Address to Muslim Leaders [2011-09-23]
"We Believers Have a Special Contribution to Make Toward Building a Better World"
"We Believers Have a Special Contribution to Make Toward Building a Better World"
Holy Father's Comments en Route to Berlin [2011-09-22]
"We Are in Need of a Presence of God in Our Time"
"We Are in Need of a Presence of God in Our Time"
Pontiff's Homily at Germany's Olympic Stadium [2011-09-22]
"The Risen Lord Gives Us a Place of Refuge, a Place of Light"
"The Risen Lord Gives Us a Place of Refuge, a Place of Light"
Papal Message to Berlin's Jewish Leaders [2011-09-22]
"Strengthen Our Common Hope in God in the Midst of an Increasingly Secularized Society"
"Strengthen Our Common Hope in God in the Midst of an Increasingly Secularized Society"
Pope's Words to Germany's Lower House of Parliament [2011-09-22]
"The Listening Heart: Reflections on the Foundations of Law"
"The Listening Heart: Reflections on the Foundations of Law"
Benedict XVI's Address at Berlin Welcome Ceremony [2011-09-22]
"Just as Religion Has Need of Freedom, so Also Freedom Has Need of Religion"
"Just as Religion Has Need of Freedom, so Also Freedom Has Need of Religion"
CathBlog - Metaphysics well regarded outside the Catholic 'ghetto' by Simon Rowney (via Insight Scoop)
Labels:
academia,
analytic philosophy,
metaphysics,
theology
Thursday, September 22, 2011
Wednesday, September 21, 2011
Tuesday, September 20, 2011
Die Kirche ist von außen und innen bedroht
Predigt von Weihbischof Athanasius Schneider beim Pontifikalamt im Alten Ritus in der Wiener Karlskirche am Fest Maria Namen, am 12. September, auf Einladung der Petrusbruderschaft.
Monday, September 19, 2011
Sunday, September 18, 2011
Steven Long responds to Christopher Tollefsen regarding capital punishment
Thomistica.net: "Goods" Without Normative Order to the Good Life, Happiness, or God: The New Natural Law Theory and the Nostrum of Incommensurability
Chris Masterjohn recommends the following:
Publish-or-perish: Peer review and the corruption of science
Pressure on scientists to publish has led to a situation where any paper, however bad, can now be printed in a journal that claims to be peer-reviewed
Publish-or-perish: Peer review and the corruption of science
Pressure on scientists to publish has led to a situation where any paper, however bad, can now be printed in a journal that claims to be peer-reviewed
Saturday, September 17, 2011
Sister Matthaia Osswald's story of conversion to Orthodoxy: My Great Adventure in Search of the Truth
A Catholic can't help but scrutinize her reasons for converting, and the importance of the Divine Liturgy in the process.
A Catholic can't help but scrutinize her reasons for converting, and the importance of the Divine Liturgy in the process.
Fr. Giertych has already been down to TAC. He will be in Berkeley next Tuesday. As my car is in the shop, I do not know if I will be able to attend, but I will post the video if it becomes available.
An interview of Wojciech Giertych, O.P. by the Province of St. Joseph.
Post-production for Master of the Sacred Palace was completed in May, but no news of when the DVD will be released. A post about him and his duties at Pro Unione.
His course on moral theology.
An interview of Wojciech Giertych, O.P. by the Province of St. Joseph.
Post-production for Master of the Sacred Palace was completed in May, but no news of when the DVD will be released. A post about him and his duties at Pro Unione.
His course on moral theology.
Friday, September 16, 2011
A typical NNLT appeal to "dignity"
Capital Punishment, Sanctity of Life, and Human Dignity by Christopher O. Tollefsen
Thursday, September 15, 2011
TED: Richard Resnick: Welcome to the genomic revolution
Haven't the reductionistic claims of geneticists been shown to be exaggerated already?
Record: LIVE chat with Lucianne Walkowicz on extrasolar planets and how that affects life on Earth, September 15, 1-3pm EDT.
Haven't the reductionistic claims of geneticists been shown to be exaggerated already?
Record: LIVE chat with Lucianne Walkowicz on extrasolar planets and how that affects life on Earth, September 15, 1-3pm EDT.
Wednesday, September 14, 2011
TED: Kate Hartman: The art of wearable communication
TED ever going to have someone talk about using less energy?
TED ever going to have someone talk about using less energy?
Tuesday, September 13, 2011
"Upright"
Online Etymological Dictionary:
Another link between "straight" [right] and being morally good? The erect position is proper to man, not only because he is a biped but a quadruped, but the natural posture is what is healthy for him as well?
O.E. upriht, from up "up" + riht "right." Similar compounds are found in other Germanic languages (cf. O.Fris. upriucht, M.Du. oprecht, O.H.G. ufreht, Ger. aufrecht, O.N. uprettr). Figurative sense of "good, honest" is first attested 1520s. The noun in the sense of "something standing erect" is from 1742.
Another link between "straight" [right] and being morally good? The erect position is proper to man, not only because he is a biped but a quadruped, but the natural posture is what is healthy for him as well?
Monday, September 12, 2011
Should I get a copy?
Rick Garnett recommends Josef Pieper's The Christian Idea of Man. A short introductory work that probably isn't as thorough as his essays on the cardinal virtues?
Zenit:
Papal Address to Engaged Couples
"Educate Yourselves Henceforth in the Liberty of Fidelity" [2011-09-12]
"Educate Yourselves Henceforth in the Liberty of Fidelity" [2011-09-12]
Papal Homily at Close of Eucharistic Congress
"A Eucharistic Spirituality Is a Real Antidote to Individualism" [2011-09-11]
"A Eucharistic Spirituality Is a Real Antidote to Individualism" [2011-09-11]
On the Virgin's "Fiat"
The Risen Christ Is the "Source of Hope and Comfort for Daily Life" [2011-09-11]
The Risen Christ Is the "Source of Hope and Comfort for Daily Life" [2011-09-11]
Sunday, September 11, 2011
Saturday, September 10, 2011
The Smithy: Henry of Ghent on Aquinas and Existence
Henry of Ghent: "The first way of understanding the participation of a creature in being is mistaken; it is not an understanding but a phantastical imagination. For the essence of a creature should not be imagined like the air indifferent to obscurity and luminosity, but like a certain ray in itself apt to subsist, produced by the sun, not by the necessity of nature but by free will."
Isn't it rather petty to complain that an analogy is a phantastical imagination rather than an understanding?
But does Aquinas think that existence and nature are two separate things? How can they be distinct without being separate in reality? How is "real" to be understood? After all, St. Thomas's and the Thomistic understanding of the real distinction is what is at issue...
Henry of Ghent: "The first way of understanding the participation of a creature in being is mistaken; it is not an understanding but a phantastical imagination. For the essence of a creature should not be imagined like the air indifferent to obscurity and luminosity, but like a certain ray in itself apt to subsist, produced by the sun, not by the necessity of nature but by free will."
Isn't it rather petty to complain that an analogy is a phantastical imagination rather than an understanding?
Thomas' image of the air's illumination is an image of one sort of thing being poured into another sort of thing to make it actual in a certain way, but for Henry (and, I might add, the Franciscan tradition in general along with him) existence can't be understood as a different sort of thing than the existing nature and added to it in order that it can be.
But does Aquinas think that existence and nature are two separate things? How can they be distinct without being separate in reality? How is "real" to be understood? After all, St. Thomas's and the Thomistic understanding of the real distinction is what is at issue...
Labels:
Franciscan school,
metaphysics,
St. Thomas Aquinas
Friday, September 09, 2011
Discussion of Peter Moskos's book on punishment
Public Discourse: Flogging: The Best Hope for Our Broken Prison System? by Stefan McDaniel
More on the book.
More on the book.
Thursday, September 08, 2011
Wednesday, September 07, 2011
Tuesday, September 06, 2011
Zenit: On Beauty as a Way to God
Art "Is Like a Door Opened to the Infinite"
Sandro Magister, Ratzinger's Favorite Bach Cantata
It is the one for the last Sunday of the Lutheran liturgical year, centered on the parable of the wise and foolish virgins. All the details of a personal memory of Pope Benedict, on the eve of his next voyage to Germany
Art "Is Like a Door Opened to the Infinite"
Sandro Magister, Ratzinger's Favorite Bach Cantata
It is the one for the last Sunday of the Lutheran liturgical year, centered on the parable of the wise and foolish virgins. All the details of a personal memory of Pope Benedict, on the eve of his next voyage to Germany
Monday, September 05, 2011
Sunday, September 04, 2011
Righteous
What are the Greek and Hebrew words which are translated by the word "righteous" or "just"? The Online Etymological Dictionary has the following for "righteous":
And for right:
The word can describe a person with respect to his actions in relation to God. (His moral orientation?) Is this what is conveyed by the Hebrew and Greek?
early 16c. alteration of rightwise, from O.E. rihtwis, from riht (see right) + wis "wise, way, manner." Suffix altered by influence of courteous, etc. Meaning "genuine, excellent" is c.1900 in jazz slang. Related: Righteousness.
And for right:
"Straight" as describing the path one takes [to God]?right (adj.1)"morally correct," O.E. riht "just, good, fair, proper, fitting, straight," from P.Gmc. *rekhtaz (cf. O.H.G. reht, Ger. recht, O.N. rettr, Goth. raihts), from PIE base *reg- "move in a straight line," also "to rule, to lead straight, to put right" (see regal; cf. Gk. orektos "stretched out, upright;" L. rectus "straight, right;" O.Pers. rasta- "straight, right," aršta- "rectitude;" O.Ir. recht "law;" Welsh rhaith, Breton reiz "just, righteous, wise").
The word can describe a person with respect to his actions in relation to God. (His moral orientation?) Is this what is conveyed by the Hebrew and Greek?
Labels:
biblical theology,
etymology,
grace,
infused virtues,
justice
Coming up at the Church of St. Vincent Ferrer, NYC
OpStJoseph: Solemn Vespers for All Saints Eve
Liturgy and Lecture at St. Vincent Ferrer with Fr. Uwe Michael Lang
By Fr. Lang:
The Reform of the Liturgy and the Position of the Celebrant at the Altar
The Language of Liturgical Celebration
How Latin Could Serve as a "Bond of Unity"
Fr. Uwe Michael Lang on Latin in the Liturgy
Liturgy and Lecture at St. Vincent Ferrer with Fr. Uwe Michael Lang
By Fr. Lang:
The Reform of the Liturgy and the Position of the Celebrant at the Altar
The Language of Liturgical Celebration
How Latin Could Serve as a "Bond of Unity"
Fr. Uwe Michael Lang on Latin in the Liturgy
Saturday, September 03, 2011
John Deely has been busy.
But is he rewiting the same book? From U. of Scranton Press:
Descartes and Poinsot: The Crossroad of Signs and Ideas
Augustine and Poinsot: The Protosemiotic Development
Medieval Philosophy Redefined: The Development of Cenoscopic Science, AD354 to 1644 (From the Birth of Augustine to the Death of Poinsot)
Forthcoming
Intentionality and Semiotics: A Story of Mutual Fecundation (also available)
Did he take his history of philosophy and expand certain chapters?
Four Ages of Understanding: The first Postmodern Survey of Philosophy from Ancient Times to the Turn of the Twenty-First Century (GB)
Descartes and Poinsot: The Crossroad of Signs and Ideas
Augustine and Poinsot: The Protosemiotic Development
Medieval Philosophy Redefined: The Development of Cenoscopic Science, AD354 to 1644 (From the Birth of Augustine to the Death of Poinsot)
Intentionality and Semiotics: A Story of Mutual Fecundation (also available)
Did he take his history of philosophy and expand certain chapters?
Four Ages of Understanding: The first Postmodern Survey of Philosophy from Ancient Times to the Turn of the Twenty-First Century (GB)
A commendable article by Dr. Kevin White
In the Spring 2011 issue of Nova et Vetera, "Aquinas on Good Will." I find the essay's organization to be rather appealing and something I would like to emulate; if only others could be as clear and rigorous in as Dr. White in their writing and presentation.
Labels:
Aristotle,
charity,
friendship,
Kevin White,
St. Thomas Aquinas,
virtues
Friday, September 02, 2011
Thomistica.net: The Aquinas Center of Ave Maria University and the 'New' Thomistica.Net
The university has a lot of good people, but will it ultimately survive the bad leadership of the past? It looks like there are plans to publish the proceedings for the conference honoring Ralph McInerny:
The university has a lot of good people, but will it ultimately survive the bad leadership of the past? It looks like there are plans to publish the proceedings for the conference honoring Ralph McInerny:
In pursuit of this aim, The Aquinas Center hosts international conferences on the thought of Aquinas, grants annual awards for superlative books and dissertations written on the thought of Aquinas, and publishes substantial volumes on Aquinas’ thought. These volumes include, to date, Reading John with St. Thomas (CUA Press), Aquinas the Augustinian (CUA Press), Rediscovering Aquinas and the Sacraments (Hillenbrand Books), Reading Romans with St. Thomas (in preparation), and a forthcoming volume on the role of philosophy in theological education in honor of Ralph McInerny.
Ralph McInerny on rights
Updating some links: On Natural Law and Natural Rights and Natural Law and Human Rights.
The Precepts of Natural Law
There is a very good article in the January 2011 issue of The Thomist by Randall Smith, "What the Old Law Reveals about the Natural Law." I think St. Thomas's discussion of the moral precepts of the Old Law does illuminate his teachings about Natural Law and the first principles of practical reason. However, it is curious that Smith reduces the Natural Law to the two great commandments:
A reminder about St. Thomas on the fppr:
(The Latin: "Et ideo primum principium in ratione practica est quod fundatur supra rationem boni, quae est, bonum est quod omnia appetunt. Hoc est ergo primum praeceptum legis, quod bonum est faciendum et prosequendum, et malum vitandum.")
Related:
SEP: Medieval Theories of Practical Reason
IEP: Medieval Theories of Practical Reason
Germain Grisez, "The First Principle of Practical Reason: A Commentary on the Summa Theologiae, 1-2, Question 94, Article 2"
Kelsen and Aquinas on “the Natural-Law Doctrine” by Robert P. George
An Overview of Practical Reason on Aquinas
THE LOGIC OF NATURAL LAW IN AQUINAS'S "TREATISE ON LAW" James Fieser
The natural law is grounded in two general, invariable precepts, which are invariable with respect to both rectitude and knowledge: to love God and to love neighbor as oneself. The natural law also contains a series of more specific precepts derived from these first-level, general, invariable precepts (135).Did he not remember I II 100, 5 ad 1?
Now there was need for man to receive a precept about loving God and his neighbor, because in this respect the natural law had become obscured on account of sin: but not about the duty of loving oneself, because in this respect the natural law retained its vigor: or again, because love of oneself is contained in the love of God and of one's neighbor: since true self-love consists in directing oneself to God. And for this reason the decalogue includes those precepts only which refer to our neighbor and to God.According to Aquinas, there is a precept to love one's self, but it was not necessary for it to be promulgated as a separate commandment from God.
A reminder about St. Thomas on the fppr:
Now as "being" is the first thing that falls under the apprehension simply, so "good" is the first thing that falls under the apprehension of the practical reason, which is directed to action: since every agent acts for an end under the aspect of good. Consequently the first principle of practical reason is one founded on the notion of good, viz. that "good is that which all things seek after." Hence this is the first precept of law, that "good is to be done and pursued, and evil is to be avoided." All other precepts of the natural law are based upon this: so that whatever the practical reason naturally apprehends as man's good (or evil) belongs to the precepts of the natural law as something to be done or avoided.I think this post at Siris, On Grisez on the First Principle of Practical Reasoning, goes too far to make a distinction between the first principle of practical reason and the first principle of law, as it says the first principle of practical reason is "one founded," not that it is.
(The Latin: "Et ideo primum principium in ratione practica est quod fundatur supra rationem boni, quae est, bonum est quod omnia appetunt. Hoc est ergo primum praeceptum legis, quod bonum est faciendum et prosequendum, et malum vitandum.")
Related:
SEP: Medieval Theories of Practical Reason
IEP: Medieval Theories of Practical Reason
Germain Grisez, "The First Principle of Practical Reason: A Commentary on the Summa Theologiae, 1-2, Question 94, Article 2"
Kelsen and Aquinas on “the Natural-Law Doctrine” by Robert P. George
An Overview of Practical Reason on Aquinas
THE LOGIC OF NATURAL LAW IN AQUINAS'S "TREATISE ON LAW" James Fieser
Thursday, September 01, 2011
Fr. Cessario on casuistry
The appendix to Introduction to Moral Theology.
Rather than putting all of the blame for the laity developing a distorted understanding of obedience on the Jesuits (as Geoffrey Hull does in A Banished Heart, iirc), should we attribute it instead to the general intellectual and cultural trends following Trent? Was this development in Christian moral theology mirrored by secular trends in understanding ethics in the 18th and 19th centuries? I can see how it would be in the interest of those in power to create docile citizens, but this is always the case, as we see in Aristotle's differentiation of the good citizen from the good man.
Regarding the appraisal of pre-conciliar treatments of sexual morality, we should keep these comments by Fr. Cessario in mind:
The "Jansenistic" attitude towards sex may not have been due to formal or even cultural Jansenism, but a "practical" Jansenism arising from the dominance of casuistry?
Rather than putting all of the blame for the laity developing a distorted understanding of obedience on the Jesuits (as Geoffrey Hull does in A Banished Heart, iirc), should we attribute it instead to the general intellectual and cultural trends following Trent? Was this development in Christian moral theology mirrored by secular trends in understanding ethics in the 18th and 19th centuries? I can see how it would be in the interest of those in power to create docile citizens, but this is always the case, as we see in Aristotle's differentiation of the good citizen from the good man.
Regarding the appraisal of pre-conciliar treatments of sexual morality, we should keep these comments by Fr. Cessario in mind:
The liberty of indifference favors a dualist anthropology insofar as the theory envisions the will as set over and against the rest of the powers of the human person. This may explain why casuist moral theology took a disproportionate interest in regulating sexual morality. No greater threat to the liberty of indifference could be imagined than the sudden upsurge of bad lust. So every precaution had to be taken to maintain the serene "indifference" of the will in the face of some de facto, especially unexpected, compelling good. Recall that, according to the casuist theorists, no factor outside of the will itself could set human willing effectively upon a particular course of action (238).
The "Jansenistic" attitude towards sex may not have been due to formal or even cultural Jansenism, but a "practical" Jansenism arising from the dominance of casuistry?
James Chastek, A (sort of) Thomistic divine command theory
I'm curious as to why command is described as a "procession from the will" as opposed to something pertaining to reason. When imposed on another, it does involve the will of the law-giver.
Related:
Introduction to Moral Theology
The Pinckaers Reader
“Command” is an analogous term, that is, the meanings of “[human] command” and “divine command” are in one sense the same and in another sense different. They are the same so far as, when considering a command, we view it as either (a) a procession from the will or (b) a normative being. But the sense in which a human command is an (a) and (b) is not the same as the way a divine command is. The unity we find between (a) and (b) in human commands must be negated when speaking of divine commands.
I'm curious as to why command is described as a "procession from the will" as opposed to something pertaining to reason. When imposed on another, it does involve the will of the law-giver.
Related:
Introduction to Moral Theology
The Pinckaers Reader
Wednesday, August 31, 2011
Here it is
That dissertation I thought might be interesting: Thomas John Bushlack, Justice in the Theology of Thomas Aquinas: Rediscovering Civic Virtue (pdf).
Labels:
dissertation research,
justice,
St. Thomas Aquinas
Zenit: On Thinking Like God and Accepting the Cross
"To Think According to the World Is to Put God Aside"
"To Think According to the World Is to Put God Aside"
Tuesday, August 30, 2011
Let us pray for someone worthy of the office.
(via Catholic Fire)
A promotion for Augustine Di Noia? It would be good to have a traditional Dominican in charge.
Monday, August 29, 2011
While looking through the website for St. Augustine's Press today, I saw John Deely's latest in the new releases -- Semiotic Animal. It was the subtitle that really caught my eye: A Postmodern Definition of
“Human Being” Transcending Patriarchy and Feminism. What does this mean, exactly? Patriarchy and Feminism are related to the sphere of moral action though they are rooted in conceptions of sex (or gender). So does Mr. Deely attempt to downplay sex differences?
More:
A brief essay with the same name as the title of the book.
Basics of Semiotics (Semiotics page)
“Human Being” Transcending Patriarchy and Feminism. What does this mean, exactly? Patriarchy and Feminism are related to the sphere of moral action though they are rooted in conceptions of sex (or gender). So does Mr. Deely attempt to downplay sex differences?
More:
A brief essay with the same name as the title of the book.
Basics of Semiotics (Semiotics page)
Nicholas Orme
Medievalists.net: Medieval Schools: Roman Britain to Renaissance England, a post about Nicholas Orme's Medieval Schools: From Roman Britain to Renaissance England.
Orme also has a book about Medieval Children. A review of that book. (Mars Hill Audio)
Childhood in Medieval England, c.500-1500
More about Nicholas Orme:
The Devonshire Association
Orme also has a book about Medieval Children. A review of that book. (Mars Hill Audio)
Childhood in Medieval England, c.500-1500
More about Nicholas Orme:
The Devonshire Association
Sunday, August 28, 2011
Someone writes in this controversy at FPR:
Also, the desire to embrace the continuation of the Jewish religion, rather than the negation, under Christ is being rediscovered in beautiful ways. This of course, dealing with God’s covenants, His people and what marks them out as His, etc. The heavy anti-semitism, most noticeably from the 4th century on by the church, has been linked to the Greek “trinity” of Socrates, Plato and Aristotle on the Church’s approach rather than the Hebraic understanding. This is what is driving much scholarship today in the Reformed circles of Christianity. The idea of the “rediscovering” of historical context and the mindset of Judaism, the followers of this Judaic Messiah, and the sociological implications are creating much fruitful discussion. Again, this is extremely broad, but at least covers an overview of some of the main presuppositions.
The Medieval Appropriation of Aristotle
1. The medieval schoolmen studied Aristotle, that is clear. What was their purpose in doing so? Was it only for the sake of their theology? Or did they wish to learn philosophy as philosophy?
2. Did they respect the integrity and reasoning of the science, as it was laid out by Aristotle in his lectures? How seriously did they take Aristotle's treatment of the sciences? Was the predominant attitude to use Aristotle only in so far as he bolstered their theological arguments, but without looking at how his arguments fit into the rest of his sciences, as he laid them out? (If he contradicted the Faith he was corrected with a response and/or not employed.) Was their theology so important that they lost sight of the philosophical argumentation?
I have to say that from what I have read of St. Bonaventure, this characterization appears to be true for him. But what of the Franciscans who came after him, or the secular masters? One can appropriate Aristotle without learning well from him, and the early medievals may have been disadvantaged in comparison with their successors.
3. The medievals had inherited certain ways of understanding material creation, but much of this apparatus was not Divinely revealed but given by their non-Christian predecessors, for example the neo-Platonists. Still, are the Augustinian and Aristotelian accounts of the soul so opposed that they cannot be reconciled? With regards to understanding Aristotle's physics as preparation for metaphysics -- was there a problem there as well? Did some jump into metaphysics without acquiring physics first? It seems to me that the later medievals took his physics more seriously.
4. What about Aristotelian logic? I have been unable to investigate the medieval appropriation of logic and its development (especially in relation to metaphysics) I'll have to pick up a copy of Medieval Logic: An Outline of Its Development from 1250 to c. 1400 by Philotheus Boehner. Can differences between Aquinas and Scotus (or Ockham) be reduced or at least partially linked to different understandings/interpretations of Aristotle?
2. Did they respect the integrity and reasoning of the science, as it was laid out by Aristotle in his lectures? How seriously did they take Aristotle's treatment of the sciences? Was the predominant attitude to use Aristotle only in so far as he bolstered their theological arguments, but without looking at how his arguments fit into the rest of his sciences, as he laid them out? (If he contradicted the Faith he was corrected with a response and/or not employed.) Was their theology so important that they lost sight of the philosophical argumentation?
I have to say that from what I have read of St. Bonaventure, this characterization appears to be true for him. But what of the Franciscans who came after him, or the secular masters? One can appropriate Aristotle without learning well from him, and the early medievals may have been disadvantaged in comparison with their successors.
3. The medievals had inherited certain ways of understanding material creation, but much of this apparatus was not Divinely revealed but given by their non-Christian predecessors, for example the neo-Platonists. Still, are the Augustinian and Aristotelian accounts of the soul so opposed that they cannot be reconciled? With regards to understanding Aristotle's physics as preparation for metaphysics -- was there a problem there as well? Did some jump into metaphysics without acquiring physics first? It seems to me that the later medievals took his physics more seriously.
4. What about Aristotelian logic? I have been unable to investigate the medieval appropriation of logic and its development (especially in relation to metaphysics) I'll have to pick up a copy of Medieval Logic: An Outline of Its Development from 1250 to c. 1400 by Philotheus Boehner. Can differences between Aquinas and Scotus (or Ockham) be reduced or at least partially linked to different understandings/interpretations of Aristotle?
Some posts on pre-Vatican 2 treatments of marriage in moral theology. Have we really lost a lot in our understanding of sexual morality since the council? Do popular treatments of theology of the body pale by comparison?
Saturday, August 27, 2011
Original Sin
Idle and Rambling Speculations on Original Sin By Joseph Wood
The biological transmission of original sin has puzzled me, but it seems to have been taken seriously by the medievals. St. Thomas talks about the tranmission of sin and the infection of the powers of the soul. corruption of nature. What does that mean though, merely that because they are descendents of Adam that they are therefore subject to the providential order which he has caused through his sin? According to St. Thomas, no -- it is not merely a privation. So what is the corruption of nature, according to St. Augustine and St. Thomas? I need to read the relevant questions more carefully, but it may be that up to this point I have not been able to understand what St. Thomas has written because I was assuming an erroneous dualistic account of human nature, one that lead me to spiritualize original sin too much.
The biological transmission of original sin has puzzled me, but it seems to have been taken seriously by the medievals. St. Thomas talks about the tranmission of sin and the infection of the powers of the soul. corruption of nature. What does that mean though, merely that because they are descendents of Adam that they are therefore subject to the providential order which he has caused through his sin? According to St. Thomas, no -- it is not merely a privation. So what is the corruption of nature, according to St. Augustine and St. Thomas? I need to read the relevant questions more carefully, but it may be that up to this point I have not been able to understand what St. Thomas has written because I was assuming an erroneous dualistic account of human nature, one that lead me to spiritualize original sin too much.
Friday, August 26, 2011
Mark F. Johnson, On the future of Thomistica.net
The great news is that the site will remain sure-footed under the direction and support of the people at The Aquinas Center at Ave Maria University, will in fact have a larger base of fine and diverse contributors, and will assuredly expand its viewership to an ever-widening audience of those interested in the academic study of St. Thomas Aquinas. Roger Nutt will be overseeing the site, with help of Michael Dauphinais and Joseph Trabbic. The new contributors will include Fr. Matthew Lamb and Steven Long of Ave Maria and Christopher Malloy of the University of Dallas and Fr. Timothy Bellamah of the Dominican House of Studies.
Thursday, August 25, 2011
Wolfgang Smith, The Quantum Enigma
Edit. The videos are not of Wolfgang Smith, but someone giving a presentation on Smith. His book, The Quantum Enigma.
Response to the talk
Wolfgang Smith: Science and Myth, The Hidden Connection, The Plague of Scientistic Belief
profile for Wolfgang Smith
Sacred Web
The Foundation for Traditional Studies
Sophia Perennis
Response to the talk
Wolfgang Smith: Science and Myth, The Hidden Connection, The Plague of Scientistic Belief
profile for Wolfgang Smith
Sacred Web
The Foundation for Traditional Studies
Sophia Perennis
Labels:
apologetics,
ecumenism,
philosophy of science,
scientism,
Wolfgang Smith
Wednesday, August 24, 2011
Zenit: Papal Message on Liturgy as Source of Catechesis
"The Liturgy Is Not What Man Does, But What God Does"
"The Liturgy Is Not What Man Does, But What God Does"
Labels:
Benedict XVI,
catechesis,
liturgy,
Sacrosanctum Concilium
Sandro Magister, After Madrid. How Benedict XVI Has Innovated the WYD
There are at least three innovations that characterize the World Youth Days with this pope: moments of silence, the very young age of the participants, the passion to witness to faith in the world
There are at least three innovations that characterize the World Youth Days with this pope: moments of silence, the very young age of the participants, the passion to witness to faith in the world
Certain traditionalists remain critical.
Dominican School of Philosophy and Theology:
Papal Theologian's Talk
Tuesday, September 20, 7:30 pm
DSPT will have the honor of hosting Fr. Wojciech Giertych, OP, a Dominican friar of the Polish Province who is the Theologian to the Papal Household. Fr. Giertych will speak on "Virtuous human action-- an icon of God. Aquinas's vision of Christian morality." Download flyer for the Papal Theologian Talk
DSPT Galleria
Tuesday, August 23, 2011
Ite ad Thomam: Berry: Ecumenical Councils are Not Entirely Infallible
Labels:
ecclesiology,
ecumenical councils,
infallibility,
Magisterium
Monday, August 22, 2011
MoJ: Natural Law, "positivism", judging, etc.
The post links to a paper by Michael Baur on the interpretation of the law by judges.
Hrm... how does the separation of powers play out? Would it be possible to give judges the authority to rule as to whether a law was just or not?
The post links to a paper by Michael Baur on the interpretation of the law by judges.
Hrm... how does the separation of powers play out? Would it be possible to give judges the authority to rule as to whether a law was just or not?
Sunday, August 21, 2011
Saturday, August 20, 2011
Zenit: Holy Father's Words to University Professors
"You Provide a Splendid Service in the Spread of Truth"
"You Provide a Splendid Service in the Spread of Truth"
Friday, August 19, 2011
Subscribe to:
Comments (Atom)